On this page
Criminal Justice Package 2026: Fair Trials responds to proposals on Europol and the European Investigation Order
From sweeping changes to Europol’s mandate to the introduction of a new instrument of mutual recognition, the European Commission presses ahead with its agenda to streamline and expand the Union’s criminal justice architecture.
On 24 June 2026, the European Commission published a package of reform proposals “to strengthen the EU’s response to an evolving criminal landscape.” The package encompasses two regulations to enhance the mandates of Europol and Eurojust, respectively; a recast of the European Investigation Order (EIO), including the introduction of a new European Remote Participation Order (ERPO) that would allow suspects and accused persons and victims to appear remotely in cross-border criminal hearings; and finally, a set of targeted updates to the Data Protection Regulation for Union institutions and bodies.
Having scrutinised the proposals, we decided to focus our advocacy efforts on the two instruments whose adoption most directly engages our core mandate: the effective protection of the rights of the defence. We regret that both the Europol proposal and the EIO proposal contain considerable defects in this regard. Our position papers are designed to explain what these defects are, why they deserve attention, and how they should be alleviated. The aim is to help the co-legislators make meaningful amendments as the proposals progress and ensure that greater efficiency in judicial and law enforcement cooperation is accompanied by equally robust procedural safeguards to protect the fairness of the proceedings.
We gratefully acknowledge that these position papers have been informed by a number of consultations of Fair Trials’ Legal Experts Advisory Panel (LEAP) and, in particular, by the insights and experiences of our network of criminal practitioners.
A paradigm shift: Europol
The Commission proposes to repeal the current Europol Regulation and replace it with an enhanced and more structured mandate organised around three interrelated functions.
Europol as “information hub”
Europol would be transformed into a centralised intelligence agency. Key features include the systematic sharing, cross-checking and querying of data at scale, both byand among Member States and Europol and through cooperation with private parties and third countries; as well as a lowering of data processing and retention standards, including with respect to data subject categories under Annex II, biometric data, data of persons under the age of 18, and data obtained through human rights violations.
Europol as “operational hub”
Europol would gain greater powers to steer national investigations, including through deployments and the establishment of Europol support offices within national units.
Europol as “technology and innovation hub”
Europol would engage in the development, testing, validation, scaling and integration of advanced capabilities, including AI-enabled applications and decryption tools, with a view to embedding these technologies into national law enforcement operations.
Taken together, these changes mark a significant departure from Europol’s current role as a merely “supportive” law enforcement agency. While this could come with equally significant efficiency gains, Fair Trials is taken aback by the complete absence of safeguards to protect the rights of the defence. Our position paper, therefore, makes detailed recommendations for a suite of crucial amendments and, above all, urges the co-legislators to impose transparency and accountability obligations on an agency which is notorious for lacking both.
You can download the Europol position paper here.
Important improvements and continuous failings: EIO
The Commission’s proposal to recast the EIO follows the Council’s final report on the 10th round of mutual evaluations on the implementation of the Directive. It seeks to promote the consistent interpretation of the EIO in practice and creates a set of common procedures and safeguards for remote participation in criminal hearings from another Member State.
Changes to the EIO
The proposal contains a range of welcome changes and clarifications, notably on the availability of legal remedies in cases where an EIO is issued for obtaining evidence that is already in the possession of the executing State; the subsequent use and onward transfer of information and evidence for use in other proceedings; and the relationship between cross-border surveillance under the EIO and cross-border surveillance under Art. 40 of the Convention Implementing the Schengen Agreement.
Introduction of the ERPO
The ERPO is meant to address the fragmented legal landscape currently governing remote participation in cross-border criminal hearings, reduce the rate of cross-border trials in absentia, and avoid the issuance of a European Arrest Warrant where physical surrender is unnecessary or disproportionate. Despite being part of the EIO Directive, the ERPO is not restricted solely to hearings for the purpose of gathering evidence.
The changes to the EIO are, for the most part, a step in the right direction and show that the Commission has taken note of the concerns raised in consultations and litigation—but they do not resolve these concerns in a comprehensive way and reveal a tendency to put the needs of the prosecution over the rights of the defence. Similarly, the ERPO is flanked by a number of vital safeguards but falters on the most essential requirements: consent and representation. Our position paper makes detailed recommendations to ensure that the proposal achieves its stated objectives without undermining the fairness of the proceedings.
You can download the EIO position paper here.