Strategic Litigation

Fair Trials and ECBA Intervene in ECtHR Cases on EncroChat and Sky ECC Evidence: Safeguarding Defence Rights in Cross-Border Proceedings

Published: (Last updated: )

Fair Trials and the European Criminal Bar Association have submitted a joint third-party intervention before the European Court of Human Rights in Isha and Emmen v. Norway, concerning the use of evidence obtained through the EncroChat and Sky ECC operations in criminal proceedings.
The intervention follows Fair Trials’ earlier submission in Silgir (No. 2) v. Germany, concerning EncroChat evidence, and its joint intervention with the ECBA in Raal and Reudolph v. Estonia, concerning ANOM evidence. Together, these interventions seek to assist the Court in establishing fundamental rights standards governing the collection, exchange and use of encrypted communications evidence in cross-border criminal proceedings.

The forensic dimension

EncroChat and Sky ECC relied on different methods of obtaining communications data, each presenting distinct risks for the authenticity, integrity and reliability of the evidence.

Fair Trials and the ECBA argue that these technical differences must be taken into account when assessing the evidence used in criminal proceedings. They emphasise the importance of preserving and documenting electronic evidence, and ensuring that the defence has access to sufficient technical records, including chain-of-custody information and integrity-verification mechanisms, to meaningfully challenge its reliability.

The fair trial dimension

The intervention addresses the safeguards required where the defence cannot access the underlying communications data or the full chain through which evidence was obtained and processed.

Fair Trials and the ECBA emphasise that restrictions on access to evidence must be accompanied by effective safeguards to ensure equality of arms, including meaningful judicial scrutiny. In particular, defendants should not be expected to identify specific irregularities or request potentially exculpatory material from datasets they have never been permitted to examine.

Broader context

The intervention builds on Fair Trials’ earlier work in Silgir (No. 2) v. Germany and Raal and Reudolph v. Estonia, seeking to contribute to the development of fundamental rights standards governing the use of electronic evidence in cross-border criminal proceedings.

As international law enforcement cooperation continues to expand, the principles established by the ECtHR in these cases will be important in ensuring that the exchange of electronic evidence does not undermine fundamental fair trial guarantees.

Fair Trials would like to thank the European Criminal Bar Association and our LEAP member Christian Lödden for their invaluable contributions to this intervention.

Read our joint intervention with the ECBA here.